Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Rumor Mill (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   2012 Game? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=94932)

EricH 13-09-2011 17:58

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Travis Hoffman (Post 1076953)
Yup, we were at Raleigh.

Let's say your alliance minibots are the other alliance's scoring pucks. Program them to evade the big robots - self-preservation mode.

Gee folks, wouldn't that be fun? I forget - was duct tape a legal minibot part last year?

Sadly, no...

But the real puck would be those Tetrix motors. 1 of those worth the same as a minibot, except that you put about 5x as many out there...so the minibot is 5x more, plus a per-motor point bonus.

Travis Hoffman 13-09-2011 18:07

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by EricH (Post 1076954)
Sadly, no...

But the real puck would be those Tetrix motors. 1 of those worth the same as a minibot, except that you put about 5x as many out there...so the minibot is 5x more, plus a per-motor point bonus.

Don't forget unused Tetrix motor gearboxes.

Robert Cawthon 14-09-2011 13:33

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Travis Hoffman (Post 1076948)
Well, you need a puck, don't you? :)

We need a like button on this like we have of facebook. Love the comment.

GlassPrison142 14-09-2011 18:03

Re: 2012 Game?
 
I bet this has already been said before, but I guess for the minibots it could be a cool idea

Like to release Minibots into a certain area of the field that the main robot can't get to, that would unlock some sort of other game piece or part of the field that would work to your advantage greatly. Or have a minibot crawl in a passage to hit something again, but horizontal and on the ground? Idk just some ideas. I don't know if the GDC would use minibots right after this year though. I hope not. Our attempt at making one was just catastrophic.

Macdaddy549 17-09-2011 21:01

Re: 2012 Game?
 
The mini bot was way to expensive and time consuming. We went through several motors and several teams had said the same to me this summer.

Andrew Lawrence 17-09-2011 21:47

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Please no more minibots! At least not for a while. Not only were they time and money consuming, but they got old and repetitive really fast, and ensured a win if used in a regional. Plus, I like to have a new endgame each year.

Walter Deitzler 17-09-2011 22:17

Re: 2012 Game?
 
I would like to see minibots again, but maybe worth not as many points.

I do like the idea of using minibots as pucks for a hockey game. "There's the minibot, lets get it!" *Thawk* :p

Andrew Lawrence 17-09-2011 22:37

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LedLover96 (Post 1077475)
I do like the idea of using minibots as pucks for a hockey game. "There's the minibot, lets get it!" *Thawk* :p

Funny story. That's sorta what happened to us at SVR. Someone hit us hard enough for one of our minibots to fall off, and each team, including our alliance members, seemed to take turns running it over. None on purpose, but it seemed that each robot got close enough to hit it. In fact, one of our neodymium magnets is still stick to a robot that ran it over! :yikes:

EricH 17-09-2011 23:11

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Macdaddy549 (Post 1077467)
The mini bot was way to expensive and time consuming. We went through several motors and several teams had said the same to me this summer.

That's partly a function of requiring a single motor type that wasn't quite up to the task before teams figured out how to deal with that. I bet if they'd given the option of 2 Tetrix or a single Banebots-type motor, there would have been quite a few teams using the BB--and a lot fewer problems.

The minibot itself should return. Just not the motors from this year.

vic burg 17-09-2011 23:40

Re: 2012 Game?
 
I think a new endgame would be cool. Maybe not minibots but some the robot deploys just in general. Climbing ramps at the end would be nice again. I think the last one of that (when we had to climb each other, too) was..... Aim High?

EricH 17-09-2011 23:42

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by vic burg (Post 1077489)
I think a new endgame would be cool. Maybe not minibots but some the robot deploys just in general. Climbing ramps at the end would be nice again. I think the last one of that (when we had to climb each other, too) was..... Aim High?

Not counting the bumps and tower hangs in 2010, that would be 2007's Rack n' Roll (other robots) or 2006 (Aim High, the ramps under the goals). Beyond that, there's the hanging bars from 2004 (and 2000), the zones to be in (2005, 2002, 2001), and the ramp to be on top of (2003).

GlassPrison142 18-09-2011 10:36

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Even though our mentor has us building an A frame arm prototype before build season, I really think this year is going to be a shooting game. The last one they did was Aim High. (Lunacy doesnt really count as a shooting, that was more like throwing up) I really don't think they'll do an arm type game two years in a row, but we'll see wont we?

vic burg 18-09-2011 11:35

Re: 2012 Game?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by EricH (Post 1077490)
Not counting the bumps and tower hangs in 2010, that would be 2007's Rack n' Roll (other robots) or 2006 (Aim High, the ramps under the goals). Beyond that, there's the hanging bars from 2004 (and 2000), the zones to be in (2005, 2002, 2001), and the ramp to be on top of (2003).

Ah! I forgot about the hanging on the bars in 2010! The years kind of blend together after awhile..... lol. The hanging bars were fun. I liked 2004's better than 2010's (I didn't play in either game though, as I was on a team between that time.).
I liked the climbing of other bots. It was a challenge for some.

Tetraman 18-09-2011 11:57

Re: 2012 Game?
 
I'd like to see more of that Robot-to-Robot interaction for the end game, specifically where your robot needs to have specific designs to allow it. 2007's end game might have been the coolest end game of all time - specifically the robots that actually lifted their teammates.

More A-Bombs in FIRST will really bring out the teamwork and heighten the excitement of elimination games.

KevinGoneNuts 20-09-2011 03:27

Re: 2012 Game?
 
I don't know if this has been posted or not, but I think it would be cool to see a game where you had to score on a robot that moved autonomously on the field. Kind of like lunacy, but with a robot that ran around the field purposely avoiding the other robots..

I can't even imagine the amount of work that would take on FIRST's part, but none the less, I think it would be cool.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:20.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi