Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   1999 (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   An idea for the 2000 games..(is six weeks enough?) (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=9914)

archiver 23-06-2002 23:17

Re: An idea for the 2000 games..(is six weeks enough?)
 
Posted by Kyle Huang.

Student on team #192, Gunn Robotics Team, from Gunn High School and Sun Microsystems, Nasa/Ames and Xerox PARC.

Posted on 7/30/99 3:08 AM MST


In Reply to: Re: An idea for the 2000 games..(is six weeks enough?) posted by Dodd Stacy on 7/29/99 2:50 PM MST:



I don't know about every other team, but the floppies GRT recieved at kickoff were a lot softer than the ones
used in competition. By this I mean they were packed with fewer styrofoam packing peanuts. This effected
our robot construction process, because we initially had a mechanism to pick up floppies from the playing
field, instead of relying on the human player. The 'conveyor' was working, but at the last minute we found
out our robot was overweight and the conveyor had to be completely removed from our robot. The floppies
we got in the kit worked with the conveyor system, because the conveyor worked in such a way that it
could only pick up floppies that were pretty soft (ie not filled up completely). The floppies used in competition
would not have worked, and our conveyor system would have failed us. We ended up doing great without the
conveyor, however...

My point (or maybe it's a complaint) is that giving specs of game objects at any time doesn't necessarily
help out. in 1998, what if one of the balls hadn't been filled up correctly? It could cost a team valuable points.
The problem with that, is that there's almost no way to make sure everything is exactly the same... hundreds
of floppies/balls/inner tubes go out to teams across the country, then hundreds more are used in all the
regionals and in the nationals. How can FIRST make sure every floppy is filled up with the same amount of
peanuts, that every ball in competition is inflated perfeclty... I'm sure there are other little issues involved...

Anyways, just a thought that crossed my mind...

archiver 23-06-2002 23:17

Balls!
 
Posted by Dodd Stacy.

Engineer on team #95, Lebanon Robotics Team, from Lebanon High School and CRREL/CREARE.

Posted on 7/30/99 9:53 AM MST


In Reply to: Re: An idea for the 2000 games..(is six weeks enough?) posted by Kyle Huang on 7/30/99 3:08 AM MST:



:

: 'My point (or maybe it's a complaint) is that giving specs of game objects at any time doesn't necessarily
: help out. in 1998, what if one of the balls hadn't been filled up correctly? It could cost a team valuable points.
: The problem with that, is that there's almost no way to make sure everything is exactly the same... hundreds
: of floppies/balls/inner tubes go out to teams across the country, then hundreds more are used in all the
: regionals and in the nationals. How can FIRST make sure every floppy is filled up with the same amount of
: peanuts, that every ball in competition is inflated perfeclty... I'm sure there are other little issues involved...'

Kyle,

Your experience with the floppies is a case in point. If we had all made or purchased a dozen or so floppies
ahead of time and 'played' with them, we would have found out how much volume variation there can be in a
fixed weight of styrofoam peanuts, and how much the peanuts would compress/degrade with some physical
abuse.

Last year, the balls demoed at Kickoff wedged very firmly between the ladder rails. Once stuffed, they were
virtually impossible to dislodge by hitting, pushing, or poking. When we received the 10 or 12 balls we ordered
and inflated them to the specified pressure, we found the diameters to vary by +/- 2' in that small sample! All
were loose in the rails - some dropped through under their own weight! We found that the shapes were highly
variable, from spherical to egg-shaped. We also found that the weights were quite variable, and that the shape
stiffness was variable at the same inflation pressure.

FIRST ultimately refined the spec to include both an inflation pressure range AND a diameter range. By that
time, we had already committed to a strategy based on wedging the balls and developed the manipulator to do
that. It was slow, but worked killer with the big, hard demo kit pressure spec ball. With the final spec, the wedged
balls were easy for the opponents to knock out of the ladder, and our offensive strategy was thus easily defeated
by a quick opponent. I believe that, had we all gotten the balls early, we would have collectively surfaced these
issues and resolved them with FIRST well before the design/build/develop crunch. At the very least, we would have
been able to quantify the variations in a typical sample of the game objects and to develop manipulator concepts that
were sufficiently tolerant of those variations.

Dodd
:




archiver 23-06-2002 23:17

Re: An idea for the 2000 games..(is six weeks enough?)
 
Posted by Jon.

Engineer on team #190, Gompei, from Mass Academy of Math and Science and Worcester Polytechnic Institute.

Posted on 7/30/99 12:45 PM MST


In Reply to: Re: An idea for the 2000 games..(is six weeks enough?) posted by Dodd Stacy on 7/29/99 2:50 PM MST:



regarding #3... it would be nice if the balls/tubes/floppies were easier to make standard so little things like the ball pressure don't screw up carefully designed manipulators. frankly i would be impressed if FIRST knew that people would be able to throw the balls through the rails in 98! I certainly didn't see that one coming...



archiver 23-06-2002 23:17

Re: An idea for the 2000 games..(is six weeks enough?)
 
Posted by Raul.

Engineer on team #111, Wildstang, from Rolling Meadows & Wheeling HS and Motorola.

Posted on 7/30/99 1:57 PM MST


In Reply to: Re: An idea for the 2000 games..(is six weeks enough?) posted by Jon on 7/30/99 12:45 PM MST:



: regarding #3... it would be nice if the balls/tubes/floppies were easier to make standard so little things like the ball pressure don't screw up carefully designed manipulators. frankly i would be impressed if FIRST knew that people would be able to throw the balls through the rails in 98! I certainly didn't see that one coming...

Actually, I recall that at the kickoff they said they would change the spec to allow that to happen.
And indeed they reduced the size of the balls after that.

Raul




All times are GMT -5. The time now is 00:48.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi