Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   15 tooth + double sprockets (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=99292)

Andrew Lawrence 05-01-2012 19:22

15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Does anyone know where I can find #35 double sprockets greater than 15 tooth? I've searched for a while on Google, but haven't been able to find them. Andymark only has 15 tooth ones max.

Thanks! :D

Mrpalmere 05-01-2012 19:46

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
You can try mcmaster.com, they show a double strand sprocket up to 20 tooth. You may hex broach the sprockets and put them on a live axel. Use hex shaft and turn down the ends to fit your bearing. I'm sorry if you don't have the facility to do this. send me a message and I'll help you with it as I have the tools ready for your use. mrpalmere@verizon.net

Andrew Lawrence 05-01-2012 19:49

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Thanks all! I looked on McMaster and the only double sprockets they had weren't like the ones in the kit of parts, or at least didn't look like them. The one in the kit of parts is essentially the one we need, however we'd prefer a larger sprocket than what Andymark offers. Plus, a key broach is sorta what we're going for.

Ninja_Bait 05-01-2012 19:51

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Double strand is not the same as double sprocket. Double strand is meant for 35-2 chain, unlike the AndyMark-type double sprocket, which is meant for two separate loops of 35-1 chain. I don't think you can use the former as a substitute for the latter, because the separation between sprockets is too tight.

Andrew Lawrence 05-01-2012 19:54

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninja_Bait (Post 1097027)
Double strand is not the same as double sprocket. Double strand is meant for 35-2 chain, unlike the AndyMark-type double sprocket, which is meant for two separate loops of 35-1 chain. I don't think you can use the former as a substitute for the latter, because the separation between sprockets is too tight.

Yeah. Sorry for not clarifying. I need to know where I can get a +15 tooth double sprocket, not a double strand. My bad for not being clear. :o

Ninja_Bait 05-01-2012 19:58

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperNerd256 (Post 1097033)
Yeah. Sorry for not clarifying. I need to know where I can get a +22 tooth double sprocket, not a double strand. My bad for not being clear. :o

It's less a clarity issue than an availability issue. Most (probably almost all) "double sprockets" are made for double strand chain, so even I slipped up on that point from my initial Google search. Alas.

Back to the search engine!

Alternatively, make your own by bolting two sprockets together (actually, that sounds kind of fishy engineering to me...) or machine it.

Andrew Lawrence 05-01-2012 20:02

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninja_Bait (Post 1097041)
Alternatively, make your own by bolting two sprockets together (actually, that sounds kind of fishy engineering to me...) or machine it.

We're not very good in machining sprockets, and the build season isn't a time to try it out for the first time. ;)

Joe G. 05-01-2012 20:06

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
I do think double sprockets will be hard to find, especially if you want them in aluminum like the andymark ones.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninja_Bait (Post 1097041)
Alternatively, make your own by bolting two sprockets together (actually, that sounds kind of fishy engineering to me...) or machine it.

Although a machined double sprocket would probably be inherently stronger, I don't see why bolting sprockets together would be "fishy engineering." If the bolts are properly sized, there's no reason for them to fail. Bolts are used to transfer rotation between two parts on dead axles all the time, so why not between two sprockets?

Alternatively, you could simply use two broached sprockets, mounted back-to-back on the same shaft.

Dad1279 05-01-2012 20:09

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
It's a little more expensive, but you can use 2 AM sprockets & a hub, bolted together. For example, 22 tooth use 2 AM S35-22 & 1 AM0096

Edit: posts above while I was writing. I wouldn't call it "fishy engineering", multiple sprockets are bolted together often, for example, many 6 or 8 wd drivetrains have multiple sprockets bolted to wheels to power adjacent axles.

Ninja_Bait 05-01-2012 20:22

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
I just try to be wary of slapped-together, poorly thought-through, solutions, and that was very much a spur of the moment idea.

Scott L. 05-01-2012 21:42

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
http://www.3dcontentcentral.net/3DCo...aspx?id=290003

you could assmble 2 of these together on the same shaft maybe?

Madison 05-01-2012 22:11

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperNerd256 (Post 1097033)
Yeah. Sorry for not clarifying. I need to know where I can get a +15 tooth double sprocket, not a double strand. My bad for not being clear. :o

You can't; it's not really a thing that's used often in industry in my experience.

Fe_Will 05-01-2012 22:35

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Are you looking for something like this?

lemiant 05-01-2012 22:36

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Bolting two sprockets together is popular and I have used it without any problems. Any pair of AM sprockets, properly sized bolts, and spacers (possibly the AM Delrin) should be fine. If you want something proven try these:

http://www.vexrobotics.com/products/...hdwr-dual.html

Andrew Lawrence 05-01-2012 22:37

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Fe_Will (Post 1097139)
Are you looking for something like this?

I think you may have solved all of my problems! Thanks!

Madison 05-01-2012 22:54

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperNerd256 (Post 1097141)
I think you may have solved all of my problems! Thanks!

I don't want to burst your bubble, but all that does is bolt two sprockets together ;)

Andrew Lawrence 05-01-2012 22:55

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (Post 1097145)
I don't want to burst your bubble, but all that does is bolt two sprockets together ;)

aww.

Fe_Will 05-01-2012 23:05

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Madison (Post 1097145)
I don't want to burst your bubble, but all that does is bolt two sprockets together ;)

I don't know if they offer 15T with that hub. That system does allow for a double sprocket (2x single strand). I know for a fact that Linn-Gear offers the ability to weld an A (hub-less) sprocket and a B (hubbed) sprocket together as well as what ever bore and broach needed. They are open 24/7 and have great turn around times since they not only support manufacturers but our local logging industry, or what's left of it.

Scott L. 06-01-2012 00:18

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
http://challengept.com/flipcatalogue...pageNumber=126

Andrew Lawrence 06-01-2012 00:22

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scott L. (Post 1097182)

I can't tell by the picture if these will work or not. They look like it, however it needs to resemble the one from Andymark and be a key bore. I can't find anything on the page saying so.

If it works, then my problems are solved! :D

lemiant 06-01-2012 00:27

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
http://www.vexrobotics.com/products/...hdwr-dual.html !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EDIT: Fixed

Andrew Lawrence 06-01-2012 00:28

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lemiant (Post 1097186)

Error 404: Page not found. :|

Andrew Lawrence 06-01-2012 00:37

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lemiant (Post 1097186)
http://www.vexrobotics.com/products/...hdwr-dual.html !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EDIT: Fixed

Found what you're looking for: http://www.vexrobotics.com/products/...hdwr-dual.html

Looks good, but how far apart are the sprockets spaced? They need to be the same space away from each other as the ones from AndyMark are.

Plus, it's for a CIMple box output shaft, so they'll need to fit there on the key bore and everything.

EDIT: I did the math (Haven't saved the world yet, build hasn't started), and found out that if I use smaller sprockets on the wheels, I can get the preferred speed. So since I also can't find any wheel-mountable sprockets smaller than 22 teeth, does anyone here know of any smaller sprockets that are also wheel-mountable? This should be easier to find then the double sprockets.

ttldomination 06-01-2012 01:31

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SuperNerd256 (Post 1097192)
EDIT: I did the math (Haven't saved the world yet, build hasn't started), and found out that if I use smaller sprockets on the wheels, I can get the preferred speed. So since I also can't find any wheel-mountable sprockets smaller than 22 teeth, does anyone here know of any smaller sprockets that are also wheel-mountable? This should be easier to find then the double sprockets.

Well, saying you want a wheel mountable sprockets is like telling us you want an umbrella with a stick.

As you might have guessed, there are many variables about aforementioned wheel. But, using my excellent literary analysis skills, I'm going to assume you're going to be using AndyMark wheels.

Using 'small' sprockets on the AndyMark wheels can prove a bit challenging. First off, 'small' isn't very specific, but there are a couple of...regions of small.

So, from my knowledge of the Andy Mark Plaction Wheels, you can get away with a #35 chain sprocket of at least a 24 teeth without having to use the 1/4" spacers. If for some reason you need exactly 22 teeth, you're going to need to use the 1/4" space so the chain doesn't hit the wheel hub.

Any smaller than 22 teeth and you're looking at a live axle system. For this, I would recommend using the AndyMark Performance Wheels. From here, you can buy the sprockets which are hubbed with keys or hex from nearly anywhere and just slide them onto the axle.

- Sunny G.

Gray Adams 06-01-2012 01:37

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ttldomination (Post 1097201)
Well, saying you want a wheel mountable sprockets is like telling us you want an umbrella with a stick.

I think he means wheel mounted as opposed to put on a live axle.

Tristan Lall 06-01-2012 03:23

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
As to your original question, the term you want is a "double single sprocket" or "double simplex sprocket". Like these:Unfortunately, most often they seem to be typically available for ANSI #40 roller chain and larger, or British 06 chain (which I doubt would match). (Some are in China, so there's the distribution problem as well.)

There's always custom fabrication—these guys say they can make it—better still, find a sponsor to make it.

(In case you're wondering, these double single sprockets are used in some conveyor systems.)

Ninja_Bait 06-01-2012 06:41

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ttldomination (Post 1097201)
Using 'small' sprockets on the AndyMark wheels can prove a bit challenging. First off, 'small' isn't very specific, but there are a couple of...regions of small.

So, from my knowledge of the Andy Mark Plaction Wheels, you can get away with a #35 chain sprocket of at least a 24 teeth without having to use the 1/4" spacers. If for some reason you need exactly 22 teeth, you're going to need to use the 1/4" space so the chain doesn't hit the wheel hub.

The wheels (the mounting part, not the tread surface) can also be turned down to a diameter that will allow the chain walls to fit. But you're still limited to 22 teeth because of the size of the bolt circle AndyMark uses. To wheel-mount a smaller sprocket you'd have to make a new bolt circle on the wheel and sprocket somehow.

Andrew Lawrence 06-01-2012 08:54

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Ok, here's the clarification:
For my drive, there is a 15-tooth double sprocket on the CIMple box output shaft. That will be connect by #35 chain to the wheels via a 22 tooth sprocket. However, to achieve the speed desired, I will either need to increase the size of the double sprocket, or decrease the size of the sprocket attached to the wheel.

Again, thanks to all of those who have answered so far, I really appreciate it, since I'm mechanically dumb (so far). ;)

Ninja_Bait 06-01-2012 09:37

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Can you just reduce the max speed in code? Or does that cause too much of a loss in torque?

Andrew Lawrence 06-01-2012 09:41

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninja_Bait (Post 1097253)
Can you just reduce the max speed in code? Or does that cause too much of a loss in torque?

We can, but we're trying to increase the max speed. It's currently at 10.97 fps, however we want to see if we can go higher than that.

ALSO, I have noticed some people saying that by using the 22 tooth sprocket from Andymark, the chain won't fit. Is that because of the wheel, or something else? I'll be using 4" plaction wheels.

jwfoss 06-01-2012 09:47

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
On the output shaft for the transmission I fail to see the issue with simply stacking two hubbed sprockets, this may require you to face them (to get the proper spacing) but this is what AM does in the AM-Shifters.

Look at the output sprockets as shown on the drawing below:
http://files.andymark.com/amshifter-asm.pdf

McMaster has a large selection of standard #35 sprockets, however you will need to broach the keyway/hex yourself.

Ninja_Bait 06-01-2012 09:49

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

We can, but we're trying to increase the max speed. It's currently at 10.97 fps, however we want to see if we can go higher than that.

ALSO, I have noticed some people saying that by using the 22 tooth sprocket from Andymark, the chain won't fit. Is that because of the wheel, or something else? I'll be using 4" plaction wheels.
Oh, you're right, I read that backwards. durpty durp.

The 22-tooth sprocket "doesn't fit" any of the plaction wheels because the plaction wheels have a built-in hub (same size and design, no matter the wheel size) that offsets the sprocket from the wheel. The diameter of that hub is too large when you use a 22-tooth sprocket because the chain walls rest on the hub instead of the rollers resting in the troughs between teeth, which can lead to jumped chain and inconsistent driving. AndyMark sells spacers and hubs with a diameter small enough for the 22-tooth sprocket, but there is also enough material in the wheel for you to turn down the built-in hub to a usable diameter with your handy-dandy lathe.

Brandon Holley 06-01-2012 09:58

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jwfoss (Post 1097260)
On the output shaft for the transmission I fail to see the issue with simply stacking two hubbed sprockets, this may require you to face them (to get the proper spacing) but this is what AM does in the AM-Shifters.

Look at the output sprockets as shown on the drawing below:
http://files.andymark.com/amshifter-asm.pdf

McMaster has a large selection of standard #35 sprockets, however you will need to broach the keyway/hex yourself.

Justin beat me to the reply, but I totally agree with him.

I am failing to see why a double sprocket is necessary.

-Brando

ebarker 06-01-2012 10:48

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
what is the purpose of bolting together two sprockets ?

if you need two sprockets, then put two singles on the shaft.

the main advantage of the AM part is it reduces a ton of weight relative to the older method of installing two steel single sprockets.

Peter Matteson 06-01-2012 12:14

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Long ago in the dark days of pre kitbot FIRST we would buy ANSI triple roller chain sprockets and turn off the middle set of teeth on the lathe to solve this issue. Not sure if this is helpful but I know we still have a buck of these kicking around the shop.

Andrew Lawrence 06-01-2012 18:54

Re: 15 tooth + double sprockets
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jwfoss (Post 1097260)
On the output shaft for the transmission I fail to see the issue with simply stacking two hubbed sprockets, this may require you to face them (to get the proper spacing) but this is what AM does in the AM-Shifters.

Look at the output sprockets as shown on the drawing below:
http://files.andymark.com/amshifter-asm.pdf

McMaster has a large selection of standard #35 sprockets, however you will need to broach the keyway/hex yourself.

I guess we'll have to try that. Thanks! I've no experience in this, however our mechanical team should know.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:08.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi