[Laaba 80]

There is really no need for a debate on this topic. You cant state that a mentor is better than a student at being the coach, or vice versa, because it doesn't make sense. Being a mentor or student has no effect on their ability to coach during a match, it all depends on the specific individuals who want the position.

Would you rather have a 4th year senior as strategist, or a first year mentor?
From the other perspective, would you rather have a 8+ year experienced mentor, or a rookie student?

In my opinion, the best option is to allow both mentors and students the opportunity at the coaching position. Let the drivers choose who they prefer, and call it a day.