View Single Post
  #20   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 14-03-2011, 00:21
Trying to Help Trying to Help is offline
Registered User
FRC #1729 (Monadnock 4-H Robotics)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Rookie Year: 2007
Location: New Hampshire
Posts: 296
Trying to Help has much to be proud ofTrying to Help has much to be proud ofTrying to Help has much to be proud ofTrying to Help has much to be proud ofTrying to Help has much to be proud ofTrying to Help has much to be proud ofTrying to Help has much to be proud ofTrying to Help has much to be proud of
Re: Another Culture Change

JVN and others -

It's not excusable and it can, maybe, be fixed with determination and information like Michael C. spoke about. I hope. Team 1114 has helped our team with their excellent information on their website. Their ability to help and lead should never be denigrated.

Sometimes, despite all that you do as a mentor, it might not be enough. A case in point: after GSR, a friend of mine who isn't a FIRST mentor, mentioned that one of her daughter's friends had commented on how rude students from my team had been at GSR. I was shocked to hear that, let me tell you! We had gone over and over again about our expectations for behavior at any team event, never mind a competition. We talked about it quite a bit and I think I may have an inkling as to what went on. We never competed against this other student's team, so I'm thinking that it's probably a case of confusing one team with another. (And if anyone on CD can confirm this behavior rumor and give me details, please pass them along in a PM.)

BUT if I find out that it definitely was one of our students, there will be serious consequences even if it's an "explainable" case. Last year, we had a student who was spoken to by a mentor for just this sort of issue. After a second non-GP incident, he was asked reconsider his priorities and when he could come up with a plan for meeting our expectations, then we'd be happy to talk with him about his place in the team. Unfortunately, we haven't seen him since.

I know we've tried to emulate and teach a sense of fairness, helpfulness and the desire to learn from other teams. I know that we're all human and that we've probably missed some perfect teaching moments at our competition. All we can do is keep trying. I know I will.