Quote:
Originally Posted by Hawiian Cadder
personally, i would say avoid jags for any of the high current motors. the cims and rs-775's generate a lot of electrical noise, and this is what we believe to be the culprit behind our CAN problems. the Current control is very nice for some things. i think that a mix of jags and victors would probably be ideal. jags on the smaller motors where more finesse is necessary (550's, 395's) and victors or spikes everywhere else.
another reason to use victors on the high current motors is that they are typicaly in the drive-train, which means that they should have encoders on them already, and if that is the case then the sensing capability of the jag is unneeded. with voltage and speed, current and anything else you want can be calculated.
|
FWIW, we've used CAN now 2 years running (for drive train and some manipulators), and haven't had any real issues with it at competition. Sure, it can be a little finicky when getting it all set up during the build season, but once it's working, it just keeps on working. further, we've only lost 2 Jags so far... one was bricked by a bad firmware update, and the other due (we think) to metal shavings. At least, its replacement worked just fine over 2 competitions afterwards! We've seen 0 problems using jags with CIM's.