Here's a pretty simple design I whipped up fairly quickly. Basically it comes in two parts, the upright and the base. Easily disassembled for transport/storage. I envision that this would be a good trophy for the "minor" awards (i.e. anything but Chairman's, Regional Champion, maybe EI as well?). Both parts would probably be made in a mold (it'd be pretty difficult to engrave the logo and text). I feel like it'd be more durable (and less pointy!) than the current award design, and could probably survive a drop without any parts breaking off.
Fun challenge Eric! I might make some more designs later.
http://i.imgur.com/MyYYr.png
