@DJScribbles
Yeah, I recently looked at the disk again a bit more meticulously and it looks like there are actually scuffs/bubble-looking things in a small part of the disk. I'm guessing the disk was manufactured faulty which lead to certain parts being unable to be read. I have made a copy of the disk on the desktop, and through that process I've discovered the exact files that don't work. In the D:\images\CDR-R113198.1-1-00 and D:\images\CDR-R113200.1-1-00 folders on the CD, the output file is unable to be accessed normally. So, it must have just been a disk error. I believe Dusk Star might be able to load those files so I can have them by tonight, but if not I'm headed to a nearby school to use their disk.
I'll edit this again to confirm that that fixed the problem afterwards. Also, so people understand we -did- get a better laptop for my robotics team, I picked up this one yesterday:
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Toshiba+...lite&cp=1&lp=1
Ironically thanks to this we've finally been able to move past our awfully slow netbook and the classmate, so I guess this was a blessing in disguise. Sigh* if only I didn't have to be a senior now and could stay around to use this baby ._. Thanks again for everyone's help!
Edit: I got access to a CD from team 100 and it works! Thanks for everyone's help.