Quote:
Originally Posted by Akash Rastogi
Patrick- as a mentor for a decently successful rookie team in the heart of West Philadelphia with zero, and I mean ZERO, support from a school or the Philadelphia school district, I find your statement here highly irrelevant. Teams who relied on the district in the past have all died out. We are fully independent in raising money, finding a place to work, finding mentors, finding in-kind donations, and finding machining sponsors. Our main machining sponsor is located 2 hours away from our team, so please don't give the excuse that location factors into this.
|
Inspiring and anecdotal.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Akash Rastogi
A team that blames their environment for their lack of resources is, in my honest opinion, not trying hard enough. (To a certain extent)
In the end I think it boils down to the question "do you really have a problem with all these successful/resourceful teams and feel you're being cheated out of something, or do you actually have a problem with your own team and feel that you want to improve?"
|
There is a lot our team could improve on. For example, first, we need to convince the school that our existence has a purpose, and they shouldn't shut us down / lay off our only autoshop teacher in 3 years.
I don't feel cheated out of a good experience. FIRST was, without question, the best thing in my high school. I just think it would have been better if the competitions were more fair.
(Since nobody is disputing the fact that the game unfairly gives an advantage to teams that have experience, money, and mentors, I guess we can agree to disagree on the way our values work. Mine: fair -> more inspired.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by E. Wood
Having been on two teams, both of which have won Chairman's Awards (see signature below), both of which were not "an extension of whatever large corporation that sponsors them", and both of which have competitive robots year after year, I am deeply sadden and somewhat disturbed by your comments. Many of these "Elite" teams have worked many years to get to where they are today. Don't assume they "bought" their way to the top because they have large corporate names in their sponsors list because it's simply not true.
|
Never assumed anything. I think you're taking my quote out of context. I was referring to *some* top teams, and not all, and I made that clear in my post. Also, older teams have an advantage because of experience and resources. I will revise my opinion when a team with a 4 digit team number wins the overall Chairman's Award (has not happened since 1992, maybe this is the year)
Quote:
Originally Posted by E. Wood
At the actual event, we mentors back-off as much as possible and let the students do the work where they can.
|
That's great. This is how a lot of top teams work, and I have *absolutely* no problem with that. In fact, I think that the best way students can learn and be inspired by FIRST is to feel in control of the robot.
Quote:
Originally Posted by E. Wood
As for the robot, we work as team, students and mentors side by side to build the best robot possible. When we win it is always as a team, not just as a team of students or a team of mentors, but as one team of both. I believe it is this partnership between students and mentors that FIRST is looking for as it is in their mission statement.
|
Agree. Teams that don't utilize mentors well, don't do well. Unfortunately, the opposite may not be true.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ebarker
That was the tryout / interview / team bonding experience. If they don't own it they don't go.
It is only fair that the team members that earned the right to go to the competition are not accompanied by people that didn't earn the right. The students that didn't go had a year to learn about what is going on and become introduced to engineering. For whatever reason they didn't make the cut and yes that is a fairness issue.
|
Yes, what you describe is fair. Every student has a chance to experience as much as the next student depending on how much they put into the program. On the other hand, if only the kids in my team could test/interview and get into one of the elite teams in our area...