[EricH]

Originally Posted by Tuba4

I have stated what I experienced. And I am 100% sure of what I experienced. The events occurred as I recounted them.

If we can't discuss this here, where then can we?

First: It is entirely possible that both of you are correct. Either different people on a team told different people not on the team different stories, or you're talking about different events, or some combination. Either way, discussing it in public doesn't do much. And insisting that you are 100% right doesn't do much for relationships with people that disagree. There're always at least two ways to look at this sort of situation

As for where you can discuss it:

You can discuss it at the event with the team in question.
You can discuss it as a team.
You could pass it off as "maybe they got it fixed with some help and the runner wasn't told" and not discuss it beyond that.
You can discuss it in PMs.
You can even ask a general question about what someone would think about if a team told everyone they were broken only to be picked. You could put it in FAHA's mailbox or (with care) in YMTC--I think this is the kind of topic that could go in either--as a hypothetical situation.

But to post it in the way you did makes it almost an accusation of cheating--if one person can identify the team/event correctly, and makes a mistake in how they refer to it, everyone knows. And accusations of cheating tend to turn into flame wars, which we don't like. I've seen more than a few.