Quote:
Originally Posted by JR.
I will preface this by saying I think trying to predict a situation that did not happen is very difficult if not impossible. But if 1771 had picked 111 and they had declined and then picked 1114 then who would 254 had picked? With 6 opportunities to pick within the top 8 I think it is likely that 111 would have been an alliance captain. Although I can't speak for 111 but if I was in their situation and 1771 had picked me then I would have declined because I would have the aspiration of winning my division and einstein not just making it as far as possible and I would not have had a favorable chance of beating a 254/1114 alliance that also picked a 3rd bot before I did. Furthermore in a very deep division I would have had a great opportunity to pick 2 very good bots from the 7 or 8 seed and form a very scary alliance like 217 did.
I would also like to add that my opinion/comments are in no way meant to offend anyone or criticize 1771 for picking 1114 in fact I commend them on seeding first in such a stacked division.
|
While I am not offended, I would like to point out that we were one of the better scoring robots in the division last year. We did have a very favorable schedule, and that helped us seed first, but we would not be considered a middle tier robot. We knew that we couldn't break up an alliance that would in all likelihood be the Einstein champions, but we chose the team that we thought gave us the best chance to go far. We didn't do as well in the eliminations as we had done the rest of the year, but sometimes things happen. For some reason, our mini bot, which had been perfect all year, failed every time during Elims.
We chose 1114 because we thought they would give us the best chance to win. We expected to face 254/111 in the finals, but thanks to 469 playing some stellar defense on 1114, and some less than stellar play on our part, we didn't make it that far. In the exact same circumstance, I would do the same thing again.