View Single Post
  #34   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 29-04-2012, 17:01
Skinkworks Skinkworks is offline
The guy with the Fez
FRC #1302 (Team Lionheart)
Team Role: Programmer
 
Join Date: Apr 2012
Rookie Year: 2008
Location: Kernel Space, NJ
Posts: 17
Skinkworks is on a distinguished road
Re: The communication tides are shifting...

My team's robot (3142) has never had connection problems. A lot of you are saying the control system dropped your team's connection multiple times, but did anyone here do FTC last year with Samantha? Rankings in FTC were largely determined by how many times your robot worked, because no one's robot worked more than 80% of the time. You don't realize how well the FRC FCS works.

I think what FRC has to do with the control system next year is give themselves a large amount of headroom on the bandwidth, and allow use of a more expensive, more reliable radio, along with an inexpensive option for all these new Boys and Girls Club teams. FRC could also take a radio and put an alternate firmware on it (dd-wrt), use QoS for FCS messages, and throttle bandwidth on accessory streams. This could also make flashing the radio quicker, since FIRST controls the protocol.

Also, a lot of control problems could be team-related, as impossible as that seems. Going back to FTC (experiencing a similar problem), my team had constant connection issues last year. This year, my team got a new Samantha, a new brick, new code, a new RobotC version, and there was a new FCS. The only shared factor between the two seasons was me, the programmer. My team still had connection issues. It has to be me, somehow, because most other teams had much fewer connection problems. Multiple people looked at my code, and couldn't see a problem. Yes, FTC is not FRC, but parallels can be drawn.
__________________
Yes, I am the same person from the FTC forum.
FTC #248 (2009-2013): Fatal Error, Programmer, Driver, and Builder.
FRC #3142 (2009-2012): Aperture, Build, Design, and Programming Leaders.
FRC #1302 (2012-2013): Lionheart, Build Captain.
ZRHS #89 (2011-2013): Team Kühlschrank, strategist and programmer.
ZRAC #40 (2012): Catcher in the Skye, programmer.
FLL #3149 #15193 (2011-2013): Mentor.
ISR 12: Umptysquatch 6, Designer, and Builder.
FRC #???? (2013-????) Mentor.
FTC #???? (2013-????) Mentor.
FLL #????? (2013-?????) Mentor.
--
11 seasons of FIRST in 6 years. I wish I could've done more.
Reply With Quote