You have it in the wrong module and Breakout.
That's an analog module.
P.S. Great descriptive picture you took, by the way!
You have the solenoid module in slot 1. It goes in slot 3 and the analog module goes in slot 1.
Here's what the correct one looks like. Note the green LEDs on the module and the shorter Breakout with 2-pin connectors rather than 3-pin connectors.
Make sure you move the 24v wago to the solenoid Breakout. The Analog Breakout should only get 12v.
