View Single Post
  #10   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2013, 12:21
peirvine's Avatar
peirvine peirvine is offline
GOFIRST Director of Engineering
AKA: Peter Irvine
FRC #2175 (Fighting Calculators and Ri3D 'Snow Problem)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: Woodbury
Posts: 82
peirvine is an unknown quantity at this point
Re: Picking from top 8 seeds

I feel that if FIRST were to implement that rule, it would lead to some drastic strategy changes. First, it would lead to people "sandbagging" to be in 9th, so intentionally losing their Saturday matches in the hopes that they can be picked by the number 1 seed alliance. This, in my opinion, is against what FIRST is about. I feel like intentionally losing a match is not Gracious or Professional, as you are dragging down your other two partners with you.

Having the first seed pick the second doesn't always guarantee their victory. In the Minnesota North Star Regional, the number one picked the number two and the third seed alliance ended up beating them in the finals.

It is all about the luck of the draw. Anything can happen and the good teams will prevail. Plus this method leads to exciting alliance selections, such as the 2013 Northern Lights regional, where the first seed was rejected by everyone 2-6, thus making a very interesting...
__________________

2014 Northern Lights Regional-Winners (Thanks 359 and 2502)-Industrial Safety Award-Excellence in Engineering-North Star Regional-Industrial Safety-Creativity-WFFA (my dad!)-Semifinalists (Thanks 967 and 4607 (again!))
- Division Finalists (Thanks 2169 and 3284)
2013 Northern Lights Regional - Quarterfinalists, Entrepreneurship Award - Dean's List Semi-Finalist - North Star Regional - Winners (Thanks 967 and 4607), Team Spirit Award - 2013 MSHSL State Tournament - Winners (Thanks 2052 and 4607) - IRI
2012 Lake Superior Regional - Quarterfinalists, Coopertition Award - North Star Regional - Quarterfinalists, Creativity Award
-North Star Regional - WFFA Will Preska, Semifinalists
Reply With Quote