2001 Midwest Regional setting high score for the whole year. 71, 234, 111, 269
While this video doesn't capture the crowd reaction, there was a brief pause where everyone realized that the impossible had been accomplished. The crowd went silent for just a second. High score 710 which surpassed the previous high score by more than 200 points as I remember.
Watch closely to see several CD posters as students.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vsp2LjfJHsA
Oh by the way, we were beating Beatty Beast once in 2002 until our human player began scoring balls for them and we lost the match.