[LeelandS]

Okay, guys. I know the Chief Delphi reflex is to dog pile on the person who starts the thread. Here's the thing: Most of these threads turn in to heated wars about whether or not mentor coaches should be allowed. I think this is a genuine question as to why? Personally, I think a mentor or student coach fits fine into the scope of FIRST.

If it's a student; well, FIRST is about the students. Students taking control and driving their own future. So yes, a student coach fits perfectly for FIRST. The students drive, the students strategize, the students compete.

Conversely, a mentor coach is a good fit as well. Because, yes, FIRST is about the students driving their own future; though they are under the direction of professional, experienced mentors. A drive team with a mentor coach has the student driving, competing, being part of the action, while the mentor (who is absolutely forbidden from touching controls) is hanging back, supervising, providing insight and instruction.

As to why adults can't drive, well, I don't feel like that is a good fit in FIRST. As I've said and we should all know, FIRST is an organization centered around students. It doesn't seem right then for adults to take control of the teams creation if we're trying to develop and inspire students.