[NateMartin247]

I'm of the opinion that a board is good for some desicions, like dealing with sponsors, team finance, even important strategy issues, etc. But for team dynamics like leaders and drivers...

Think of it like a soccer team.
Some desicions are made by a board, like where they will play, who will coach, and how much funding the team will recieve... but what you're talking about is like having the board decide which person on the team will play forward, and who will play keeper- Only the players can make that desicion- Even if you see it as a question of captainship, the team should still make that desicion. My suggestion to you would be to hold a tryout and have the team decide based on that. Skill and dedication should be recognized here, by the team- not sway within a governing power like a board.