View Single Post
  #6   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 20-01-2014, 23:13
KeeganP's Avatar
KeeganP KeeganP is offline
Registered User
AKA: Keegan
FRC #2059 (The Hitchhikers)
Team Role: Mechanical
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 69
KeeganP is a glorious beacon of lightKeeganP is a glorious beacon of lightKeeganP is a glorious beacon of lightKeeganP is a glorious beacon of lightKeeganP is a glorious beacon of lightKeeganP is a glorious beacon of light
Re: Thoughts on Ri3D and BuildBlitz

Hey everyone. I am in no way suggesting that we discontinue/disregard that the Ri3D and Build Blitz teams did an incredible job and should be thanked for their amazing effort, skill and time commitment to making FIRST better.

All I'm suggesting is that next year they limit their production of exact resources until after build season is closer to a conclusion. I agree that teams could theoretically just turn a blind eye to all of this, but can you really control an entire FRC team's internet access? What happens when one student comes in and says "look at this robot!" or claims to have a great idea the he/she *knows* will work because they saw it already.

I think that perhaps if the teams had just waited until later to release their CAD drawings I would personally be happier -- teams couldn't just copy the robots. I understand that no robot (hopefully) will be a direct copy of it, however I think that being able to look up the exact dimensions, part numbers, etc. for building an obviously successful robot becomes degrading to a team that can no longer call their robot design original and student led. After all, what's FIRST's mission? To inspire a generation of technology leaders. Are they going to learn to think outside the box when they can download 5 different robot CAD files and combine them? Or are they just learning how to assemble a box set?

Let's keep this discussion going and how we can improve upon the Ri3D and Build Blitz ideas, rather than attacking each other's views on what "inspiration" and "cheating" are.
__________________
The Hitchhikers Team2059.org

2011 NC Regional: Rookie All Star Highest Seeded Rookie, 3459
2012 SCRIW: Champions, 2059
2013 NC Regional: Finalists, 2059 (Thank you 1539 and 2655!)
2014 NC Regional: Industrial Design Award, 2059
2014 THOR: Finalist, 2059
2015 Palmetto Regional: Gracious Professionalism Award, Finalists (Thank you 1533 and 1261!), 2059
2015 NC Regional: Industrial Safety Award, Engineering Inspiration Award, Winner (Thank you 1225 and 900!), 2059
Reply With Quote