View Single Post
  #323   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 25-03-2014, 00:46
paul_v paul_v is offline
Mentor of Team 254, previously 190
AKA: Paul Ventimiglia
FRC #0254
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Rookie Year: 2006
Location: Mountain View, CA
Posts: 16
paul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond reputepaul_v has a reputation beyond repute
Re: 301 points! and could have done more

Quote:
Originally Posted by MrForbes View Post
What was there to lose? for either side?
The side that lost in the finals would have had a better chance of winning if they also played defense. Defending the other team from scoring would help prevent them from winning. Therefore, the losing alliance would have had a better chance of winning the event.

^I wrote everything above simply and obviously stated on purpose, because I felt the question asked had a simple and obvious answer.

Imagine being a student, or sponsor, or parent of a student on the losing alliance. Try explaining to them that is was in their best interest to let the other team score unabated. Does that make them look like they were acting in their teams and team's sponsors best interests?

Furthermore, I assume most of the people in the discussions were drive coaches and drive teams. I highly doubt even a majority of the team members were asked if they really felt that was the best thing to do in the finals of a regional they were trying to win.

I would be embarrassed to be on a team that lost the event because some members decided it would be fun to spend some time of the match not playing defense and instead sitting still. If I was on the winning side? I would feel like I didn't achieve a true and satisfying win.

I am sorry for all involved, mainly the quiet students and families/sponsors who were not part of the discussions, or don't want to voice their differing opinions and feel alienated by their team mentors and leaders. You will never hear from those people on CD, only the loud ones.

-Paul Ventimiglia
Reply With Quote