Quote:
Originally Posted by who716
after reading through this forum and discussing it with my English teacher he told me that what WATCHFIRSTNOW is doing is not wrong. YouTube is a public domain full of public files, the team does not have to post there videos to you-tube. therefore Watchfirstnow has every right to take videos of of you-tube for personal use as long as its for non-private. as long as the video is not copyright, they have all the right to take it and use it.
|
Then I hate to be the bearer of bad news but your english teacher is wrong.
Compare what WFN is doing to something he MIGHT understand: I've got a lot of posts on here, some of which almost provide some educational value. Now, copy the text of that and put it verbatim into a book. Is it bad to do this without citing me? You bet it is. You're taking my work as your own. Now, yes, that work is a derivative of other's work. But the fact is that I am the one who wrote it originally.
Now, if I record an event happening is it really any different? Nope. I hit the record button, I set the angles for the shot, I did any required editing. Now, if someone takes it and uses it for their own gain (which this is undeniably doing) it is infringement. This is a really simple case.