Quote:
Originally Posted by AnonymousMarvin
First of all I still do not agree that there should have been a fouled called on the G12, the ball didn't meet any of the criterion of possession. They called it on the grounds that 4153 trapped the ball and thats what they counted as a possession; however, if you watch the video the only tapped the ball and then they immediately raised the collector. The ball was not overtly isolated, or held against a robot in an attempt to shield it so the G12 still does not apply. As for G28 maybe, but it didn't damage anything, so it would only have been a 20 point foul.
|
I don't disagree with you about G12, but recall that the "in an attempt to shield" has been completely disregarded
by the GDC in all of their Q&A answers to date.
Me? I'm not bitter.
With regard to G28, it is not available as a 20 point foul. All G28s are mandatory technical fouls.