View Single Post
  #3   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 27-04-2014, 14:46
mounikab's Avatar
mounikab mounikab is offline
Registered User
AKA: Mounika Bodapati
FRC #0384 (Sparky)
Team Role: Leadership
 
Join Date: Feb 2013
Rookie Year: 2009
Location: Sparky
Posts: 31
mounikab is just really nicemounikab is just really nicemounikab is just really nicemounikab is just really nice
Re: Championship Issues with Judging

Well, having been at championships for the past three years and the pit representative for those 3 years, judging works differently each year. With Chairman's I think they short list teams based on the submission and go from there, similarly, with a submission available for Entrepreneurship I'd think they do the same. With Engineering Inspiration on the other hand, I think judges visit every team because we (384) weren't Chairman's or EI winners at our regional but were the award winners for Galileo. Also, we have to consider that the judges must look at 100 teams total, so each team might only get one set of judges, before a short list of teams to visit is made.

I think that non-technical awards being judged in the pit is actually a good idea. Entrepreneurship, Chairman's, EI etc. are about the whole team, not solely outreach. I learn so much more visiting someone's pit and asking about their outreach when their robot is there too than I do when there's an empty pit. Having the whole team and the robot there, gives the judges and any other people the chance to really hear your team's story and truly gain an understanding of your team's core values and mission. Personally, I feel that moving the non-technical judging to a different location would be a great disadvantage, not only to the portrayal of the team story, but also to the public because they would only learn about the outreach or the robot and not how the team functions as a whole.

But that's just my two cents
__________________

FRC Sparky 384 and 2Train 395 Mentor (2014-present)
FRC Sparky 384 Student (Leadership/Outreach) (2010-2014)

World Championship Galileo Division Engineering Inspiration 2014
Virginia Regional Winners 2014
Virginia Regional Chairman's Award 2013
Virginia Regional Winners 2012
Virginia Regional Engineering Inspiration 2012
Reply With Quote