Quote:
Originally Posted by Wiifi
Noteable items: - Teams will no longer recieve Chairman's or Dean's List Feedback forms
|
Disclaimer: I have yet to read the Admin Manual.
Reaction: This is a step in the wrong direction. I get that the feedback form is flawed, but feedback is a positive thing.
Personally, I know I took great pride as both as high school student and as a mentor whenever we received feedback forms loaded with "currently strong" marks even if we didn't win the award. I also got a lot out of the comments, both in terms of where we can improve as a team and where we can strengthen our submissions.
Transparency in terms of submissions is another issue altogether, and doesn't really compare to the feedback forms. Requiring teams publish their submissions/presentations is not a replacement for feedback on your submission.