Our team switched from paper to electronic over the last couple years, and the electronic system is far easier for everyone involved. Making the scouting form is now a fun side-project for programming (see this year's at
https://github.com/FRC830/rr_scouting). The form is run on a laptop or tablet, and the results of each match are compiled into a .csv (comma separated value) file. That project also includes an excel spreadsheet with macros to import the .csv files and to compile them into a list of average values for each team. There are many other similar programs that teams have made publically available, some probably much more professional than ours.
I remember doing paper scouting, and it wasn't fun. Our team will probably be using electronic scouting for a long time to come.