View Single Post
  #27   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 23-03-2015, 12:36
ArtemusMaximus's Avatar
ArtemusMaximus ArtemusMaximus is offline
Enginerd
FTC #11722
Team Role: Coach
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Rookie Year: 2014
Location: Canada
Posts: 248
ArtemusMaximus is a name known to allArtemusMaximus is a name known to allArtemusMaximus is a name known to allArtemusMaximus is a name known to allArtemusMaximus is a name known to allArtemusMaximus is a name known to all
Re: In b4 buttongate

Quote:
Originally Posted by jds2001 View Post
Not sure what you mean here - the rules (and Q&A - in particular Q439) make it very clear that "support" is only transitive through other TOTES - not any other object that may be on the FIELD, regardless of whether it was intended to be there or not. Is this a literal interpretation of that? Yes, but if you start reading things into the rules that aren't there, then they become sort of "guidelines", not rules.

If I were a ref (which I'm not) the deciding factor for me would be if I could easily dislodge that button from the stack - i.e. is it just there on the edge of a TOTE, or is it really wedged in there? If the former, it scores - there is unambiguously no support being provided by the button. If the latter, then it doesn't score. From the picture, it could go either way. Of course, I defer to the ref at the match for the ruling, which was that it didn't score.
What I meant by Bureaucratic is this:

Overly concerned with procedure at the expense of efficiency or common sense.
Reply With Quote