View Single Post
  #134   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 09-04-2015, 12:31
scooty199 scooty199 is offline
FTC and FRC Alum, Robotics Junkie
AKA: Oscar McCullough
FRC #4472 (SuperNOVA)
Team Role: College Student
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Rookie Year: 2008
Location: United States
Posts: 56
scooty199 is a splendid one to beholdscooty199 is a splendid one to beholdscooty199 is a splendid one to beholdscooty199 is a splendid one to beholdscooty199 is a splendid one to beholdscooty199 is a splendid one to beholdscooty199 is a splendid one to behold
Re: Future First Championship News

Quote:
Originally Posted by JesseK View Post
I seriously doubt the people making the argument for some kind of Champs logistical change get on ChiefDelphi at all. I'm talking about TIMS contacts who give the FRC Teams email an earful (eyeful?) about cost/etc. I hear stories directly from local teams trying to solve the problem of getting to champs, and I know for a fact I've never seen their team # on CD. I'm sure they're emailing FIRST directly trying to get info, resources, tips, etc.

As-is FRC Champs is a logistical nightmare. Let's say the DC region went to districts, and district champs were this coming weekend. How are the district champs winners getting to St. Louis? Certainly not flying at $600 per ticket (that doesn't get us there until 3pm...). Everyone's on a bus for 15 hours at that point.

If that makes me an apologist in some eyes, well ok then. To me, the only thing we can do is take what we see/experience and make a logical, thought-out argument for/against something like this or for other similar changes.

It seems like splitting up Champs is a logical next step for FIRST in general. Personally I think it makes more sense to split up Champs by program rather than geographic location, but that's my FRC-centric 0.02.

If we go with a sports metaphor, this announcement is more like AFC/NFC Champs, and IFI is the Super Bowl. Now if only we could get ESPN covering IFI ( :: ducks and covers :: ). Though I will really miss seeing the West Coast and MI powerhouses at the same event . Given that vacation is already scarce, I doubt I could attend both events as a volunteer at one of them and a team at the other.
I agree with you on splitting it up by program.

Have a location for FRC specifically, and one for FTC/FLL. The only downside I believe would be the schools/localities that have multiple programs across different levels. That split would be awful.

I think this split will devolve into a NCAA Tournament/NIT sort of comparison with a team split soon.
__________________
Oscar McCullough
Booz Allen Hamilton - Software Engineer
Carnegie Mellon University -Mathematics, Computer Science, and Robotics


FRC 2068 - Alumni (2012)
FRC 4472 - Mentor (2013-

VRC 36130 - (2015-
VIQC 36150 - (2015-
VIQC 3615 - (2013-


FRC Team 2068: Metal Jackets Alumnus
2011/12 Chesapeake Regional Finalist Alliance
2011/12 Chesapeake Regional Gracious Professionalism Award

FTC Team 33: Enigma Alumnus
2011/12 VA FTC State Championship - Winning Alliance (Thanks 4105 and 354)
Reply With Quote