[MrJohnston]

I was concerned when the PNW went to the district model two years ago... I had all the same questions and concerns that NY teams have been raising in this thread.... Two years later, it is confirmed: the district model isn't perfect. However, the positives seem to outweigh the negatives.

Positives:
* Lower income teams that tended not to qualify for advancement, now have two events and more than double the number of matches - for $4K instead if $5K.
* Smaller events make it easier for lesser known teams to get noticed - and helped if needed.
* Nearly every team has at least one event close enough to home that hotels are not necessary. Most teams (those in more densely populated areas) have two- though some choose to do an overnight trip anyhow.
* A higher percentage of teams are able to play in an "advanced" event with a higher level of play. (Previously, it was only Champsionships after a regional.) This event has the same ambiance as a regional and costs the same amount as a regional. Moreover, a good handful of teams don't need to travel to attend.
* There is a lot of opportunity to "fix," "upgrade," and repair a robot before the next event. Allowing for an increase in student learning and robot performance.
* Overall, a stronger cross section of robots from the geographic area attend champs.

Negatives:
* Let's face it, high school gyms do not have the same "pop" as the locations used for regionals. Teams that do not make the district champs miss out on this completely.
* Teams that qualify for champs, do have additional entry fees to pay if they are to to attend over the teams that typically play in one regional, then attend champs. However, for teams that would play in two regionals anyhow, it's a wash.
* The additional one or two weekends of competition (not to mention days between!) can be taxing on mentors....and students' grades.
* Some teams believe that it lowers their chances of getting to Champs... This is true for some: Weaker robots that rely on being that last pick of the #1 alliance in a regional event will struggle to accumulate enough district points to advance past district champs. However, I don't think this is a bad thing.


Overall, I do think it has been a very good move for the PNW - and I was a skeptic at first. I would encourage all NY teams to take a good, fair, look at it. Yes, each geographic area is different, but there are many ways to account for theses regional differences in the institution of a district model for FRC.