View Single Post
  #24   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 29-12-2015, 18:16
KohKohPuffs KohKohPuffs is offline
Registered User
AKA: Daniel Koh
FRC #0299 (Valkyrie Robotics)
Team Role: CAD
 
Join Date: Jun 2015
Rookie Year: 2013
Location: Saratoga, CA
Posts: 120
KohKohPuffs has a spectacular aura aboutKohKohPuffs has a spectacular aura aboutKohKohPuffs has a spectacular aura about
Re: CADathon 2015 Challenge

Conclusion

I wouldn't say that the event was a total failure, but obviously there were some holes that affected the experience.

First, here's a list that went right:
  • For many people, this became a learning experience, as they had to make something in a limited amount of time, and it also pushed themselves to make things they never did before, for instance I was really surprised by asid61's render of all three bots
  • The event was also an opportunity to connect with people from different teams.

Now things that went wrong:
  • The "game manual"... well... it had a lot of missing elements. So much that you don't even need robots to win. There were also a lot of things unclear about the game
  • Naming conventions: My group had a parts number, but with file paths, the folder name had to be the same for all members, and that was an issue for a bit
  • The game didn't have a low goal option
  • Software conflicts wasn't a problem as much, but there was one group where they had the same software, but different versions, and that could've been fixed very easily.

Despite these things, I still plan to do another one of these during the summer, and I have a few ideas in mind that could make this better:
  • Not designing the challenge alone
  • Make it a multi-day event, so that there's more time to elaborate on some parts, and so that in case someone can't make it on one day, there's always the following day.
  • Make a better game . Perhaps even start now in designing a game

Thank you to everyone for participating, and let's hope to make the next one better!
__________________
-KohKoh

115 MVRT, Driver (2013-2015)
649 M-SET, CAD (2015-2016)
299 Valkyrie Robotics, Mechanical Director (2016 - present)
Reply With Quote