[EricH]

Originally Posted by DareDad

From a gameplay perspective it makes sense that the attacker must get out of the way of the defender.

I think the best you can expect to see is that if the defender initiates contact the attacking robot must immediately make way or suffer a foul. Otherwise attackers will be parking in there and watching for a 5 count by the ref.

I think that this would be probably what's next up. The GDC really doesn't have a whole lot of options here:

--exclude the passage contact rule from G11 entirely (won't happen, as now you've really got a can of worms)
--Clarify that the passage contact rule applies either only to initiating or regardless of initiating
--Add a new rule that if contacted, the attacker needs to be moving out right away (like the "bump-to-pass" in '08)

Personally, I'd go for the third one, but I don't think that'll make life any easier on the refs.