View Single Post
  #20   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 18-04-2016, 09:48
EmileH's Avatar
EmileH EmileH is offline
it's not a water game, ok?
AKA: Emile Hamwey
FRC #1058 (PVC Pirates) & FF (NE Way You Want It)
Team Role: Programmer
 
Join Date: Dec 2014
Rookie Year: 2011
Location: New England
Posts: 531
EmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant futureEmileH has a brilliant future
Re: Is FRC giving high CG robots a free pass on defense?

I'm going to have to err on the side of every referee, regardless of their call. The rule G24 talks about intent - as soon as any rule introduces something regarding the intent of any team, the referee cannot be held responsible for misinterpreting the intent of the team. Expect different calls from different referees. In my opinion, the way it should be is that if you flip a team, regardless if they are tall, short, etc, it should be a red card on the first offense, because the fact of the matter is that tipping other robots knocks them out for the entire match. It is not gracious or professional and drive teams should practice to avoid tipping - regardless of intent.

This issue is not that different from the infamous "Your tall opaque robot is now illegal" thread. Rules that talk about team intent are, in my opinion, highly ambiguous and I stand by the call of every referee regardless of what the call is.
__________________
2016-present: High School Student, FRC 1058 PVC Pirates
2016: RiverRage 20 Champions, Battle of the Bay 3 Champions

2013-2015: Middle School Student, FRC 3467 Windham Windup
Reply With Quote