|
Re: A Uniquely Stronghold Moral Quandry
I would propose starting from the outside and working our way in.
8111, trying to win the match, plays defense and this stops the capture: totally okay
7222 promises 8111 that they'll pick them if they stop the capture: totally not okay
8111 knows they're not going to win, already has the breach, and has no chance at the capture. They play defense - having nothing better to do - and this stops 9999's capture: totally okay
7222 asks 8111 to give up a chance to win by trying to stop the capture: totally not okay
8111 has a chance to win, but they want to get picked as a defense bot, so they play defense and stop the capture (even if it gives up winning the match): okay
8111 does the above without agreeing on it with their partners: not okay
7222 suggests to 8111 that trying to stop boulder scoring could help win the match: borderline. I feel weird about a team getting involved in a match they're not a part of. I would not do this.
I believe asking a team to do anything in a match that's not your own is inherently bad. However, morally, I think 8111 can do whatever they want, as long as they agree on it with their alliance partners (whether or not it was requested by 7222).
__________________
Team 2337 | 2009-2012 | Student
Team 3322 | 2014-Present | College Student
“Be excellent in everything you do and the results will just happen.”
-Paul Copioli
|