View Single Post
  #20   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 30-05-2016, 22:30
TheModMaster8's Avatar
TheModMaster8 TheModMaster8 is offline
Active Alumni
FRC #5492 (Robo Jockeys)
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Apr 2015
Rookie Year: 2009
Location: USA, Kentucky
Posts: 119
TheModMaster8 is a jewel in the roughTheModMaster8 is a jewel in the roughTheModMaster8 is a jewel in the rough
Re: Sheet Metal vs Tube Drivetrain

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cash4587 View Post
I really don't understand why so many people are chiming in about chain being such a problem. Chain is a very, very powerful tool if used correctly. It is even more powerful if you DO NOT use master links. After becoming familiar with the dark soul chain tool, I have to say, it is the best thing ever made for chain. Pushing the pins back in, and using the correct number of links using a chain center to center calculator is about the best thing you can use when designing mechanisms/drivetrains with chain. If you use those two things alone correctly you will never have to worry about tensioning/stretching so long as you use large tooth count sprockets and the right chain pitch for the job. My team used #35 chain for our final reduction coming off our Drivetrain gearbox with fixed direct C-C and #25 chain going from wheel to wheel direct C-C with no tensioners on either and had ZERO issues. We love chain and will continue to use it because it is easier and does not require custom belt lengths for each year or each robot.
While i can not attest to reconnecting chain, I can say with utmost confidence. that belt is by far the easier of the two. Chain stretches making it inconsistent in slop. Belt does not stretch and is more accurate, lighter, cheaper, stronger(depends what kind you get), cleaner , etc. that's one of the reasons it's used in engines (and the fact that it can run at much higher speed without oil) Don't get me wrong. chain does have it's purposes, but drive wheels without any shielding to the chain is not one. (IMO) It's wonderful when making a forklift!
__________________
2009-2011: (FLL) Robot Builder / Operator
2012: (FRC Team 2783) Fabrication / HumanPlayer / FLL Ref
2013: (FRC Team 2783) Fabrication / HumanPlayer / FLL Ref
2014: (FRC Team 2783) Fabrication Student Lead / HumanPlayer / FLL Ref
2015: (FRC Team 2783) Fab Student, Teacher / HumanPlayer / Backup Driver / FLL Ref / FLL Mentor of 6 Teams
2016: (FRC Team 5492) Fabrication Student Lead / Driver / FLL Mentor of Crestwood Elementary
Past Alliance:(2783, 1208, 4154)(2783, 1002, 4265)(2783, 1182, 3868)(2783, 451, 4028)(2783, 1208!, 1288)(5492, 63, 1014) I Will Never Forget


Reply With Quote