View Single Post
  #109   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 07-09-2016, 11:49
Brian Selle's Avatar
Brian Selle Brian Selle is offline
Mentor
FRC #3310 (Black Hawk Robotics)
Team Role: Engineer
 
Join Date: Jan 2012
Rookie Year: 2012
Location: Texas
Posts: 162
Brian Selle has a spectacular aura aboutBrian Selle has a spectacular aura aboutBrian Selle has a spectacular aura about
Re: [FIRST EMAIL] Stop Build Day Survey

Survey was super confusing. I read and re-read every question, still not sure what they were asking. My random stop build points:

1) Removing the stop build day does not remove the deadline. Your first competition is your deadline. I would argue that removing stop build day is more "real world" than the stop build loophole. Car racing, sports, design competitions - everyone prepares right up to the start of the competition.

2) When I first started mentoring for FRC and heard that others build practice robots to get around the stop build day, it didn't feel right. Either you say stop and mean stop or don't do it at all.

3) I believe the mythical "6-week build" concept is mostly about a catchy marketing phrase. It rolls off the tongue and sounds great in the elevator. Then after you've set the hook, you explain the concept of building a second robot so that you can continue practicing, their accepting smile becomes a "what"?

4) For those teams/mentors that want to stop after 6 weeks that's still an option without an official stop build day. At least you won't be lulled into thinking that other teams are really stopping work after stop build day.

5) Several years ago when we only had a few kids and a couple mentors, I remember everyone working flat out until bag day to finish the competition robot. The kids and mentors were all exhausted. We didn't have the bandwidth to build 2 robots simultaneously. We'd take a couple days off then peel ourselves off the floor and have to start building the practice robot. It certainly paid off, but felt so unnecessary. I would have much rather continued working and practicing on the competition robot.

6) Competitions would soooo much less stressful. Teams would be able to help other teams more. We would actually have time to walk around and see other teams and the exhibits. I think the level of performance of all teams would increase. How many times have you said or heard, "it worked perfectly on our practice robot"?
__________________
2015 Newton Semi-Finalist (3130, 2468, 3310, 537)
2015 Lubbock Regional Winner (2468, 3310, 4799)
2014 Galileo Quarter-Finalist (2052, 70, 3310, 3360)
2014 Colorado Regional Winner (1138, 3310, 2543)
2013 Texas Robot Roundup Winner (3310, 624, 2848)
2013 Archimedes Semi-Finalist (126, 3310, 1756)
2013 Dallas Regional Winner (148, 3310, 4610)
2012 Dallas West Regional Winner (935, 3310, 4206)
Reply With Quote