Thread: unfairness?
View Single Post
  #1   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 22-02-2002, 20:09
dense's Avatar
dense dense is offline
Registered User
#0907 (Cybernetics Core)
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Toronto
Posts: 23
dense will become famous soon enoughdense will become famous soon enough
unfairness?

After Reading the thread by Martin on unfairness...

http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/sh...=&postid=21716

...and the student/machine-shop teams VS. engineer/big-sponsor teams

The problem, imho, seems stems from the nature of this years game.

There isn't a complex strategy or challenge to acually building a neat robot. All you have to do is build a TANK and that's what most of the experienced teams and the ones I've seen are doing.

Is there a challenge in creating a TANK? The largest monster, which has the greatest gear reductiuon will win. That means the teams with the greatest resources.

There is no incentive to build an interesting robot, or to even manipulate balls.

This years challenge has become another version of BattleBot, that's right, BattleBots. Imho, that is.

If this years game depended on how creatively you could solve a problem, rather than building the biggest baddest tugging machine, then perhaps it would not depend as much on the resources of a team and make it more fair between big-sponsor/engineer teams VS. student/machine-shop teams.
__________________
let the aliens invade
-shafi, dweller of earth

- 2002 Can. Regional - J&J Sportsmanship Award
- 2002 Can. Regional - Top Rookie Seed Award
- 2002 Can. Regional - Delphi 48 "Play Of The Day Award"
- #3 seed, quarter-finalist with alliance 247 and 885

Last edited by dense : 22-02-2002 at 20:13.
Reply With Quote