[Joe Matt]

Guys, I think it isn't a problem with the rules, but more of another clash of FIRST logic, the 'kids should build and learn' over the 'mentors should build kids learn' ideas. Well, from the last perspective, it's fine, I mean, it's the final experience that counts. BUT the problem many have is in the first camp, those who think this is another thing that kids can't learn about and build. I'm in that camp. Sure, you can buy a radio and take it apart to learn about it, but nothing is better than building a radio for yourselves, because not only do you learn about the radio, but you also learn about other aspects of it, such as design, ease of use, and other things.

Is it against FIRST's rules? No. Will it help teams with money issues? Yes. But will it help kids in the long run, probably not.