|
Re: YMTC: Can teams start cutting metal for 2005?
Before debating in this kind of argument, we need to know what we consider to be 'pre-fabricated' and 'non-prefabricated'. If we cannot effectively describe what exactly it is we are for or against, then we will continue to misunderstand each other.
A component will be defined as something that has a specific function or use on a robot, and has multiple parts which make it function. Ex: a robot's chassis or a robot's arm.
A part of a component will be defined as something that has a specific purpose within a component -- something that has been intentionally altered in such a way as to serve it's purpose in making the entire component function as a whole. A part does not have a function standing alone; it must be part of an assembly to have a purpose.
A raw material has no specific function for the robot yet. Examples of raw materials are: aluminum, steel, plywood, lexan...etc.
.................
Something that has not been fabricated before kickoff:
1) Is not a component that is intended to/will be used on the 2005 robot.
2) Is not part of a component that is intended to/will be used on the 2005 robot.
3) If it is a component or a part, then it is commercially available. Ex: motors
4) Is a raw material. For example, a piece of aluminum may or may not be available commercially in a specific size, but since it has no specific function for the robot yet, it is still not a prefabricated part.
..................
Something that has been fabricated before kickoff:
1) Is a component that is intended to/will be used on the 2005 robot. Ex: an arm or chassis.
2) Is a part of a component that is intended to/will be used on the 2005 robot.
3) Is not commercially available and must be fabricated by hand for a specific use on the 2005 robot.
..................
So, according to the definitions above, I do not think it is ok for teams to be fabricating their own parts/components before kickoff. It is unacceptable and unfair to other teams. It is against the rules.
I am sure that I have not thought of everything, but I think the difference between prefab and non-prefab should be pretty clear. Teams should have six weeks to build their robot...no more and no less.
-- Jaine
__________________
Florida Institute of Technology
Ocean Engineering, '12
|