[MikeDubreuil]

Originally Posted by http://www.worldzone.net/sports/baseball/tripleplay.html

Johnny Neun -- May 31, 1927
Detroit first baseman Johnny Neun turned his in the ninth inning against Cleveland. Neun caught Homer Summa's line drive, tagged Charlie Jamieson between first and second and touched second base before Glenn Myatt could return.

George H. Burns -- Sept. 14, 1923
Boston first baseman George Burns turned his in the second inning against Cleveland. Burns caught Frank Brower's line drive, tagged Walt Lutzke off first base and ran to second and slid into the bag before Riggs Stephenson could return from third base.

It looks like both players accomplished their tripple plays against Cleveland.