In terms of aesthetics, I'd say this website is extremely well laid out with awesome contrast between different elements in the site. However, although you mention a "more design inspired layout" content also makes up a large proprotion of the website's impact. If you add more content you will definitely be a better contender for the web award.
A tip: Your header image is really well taken. Wouldn't it be better if it changed for a different link within the website?
Also your FIRST logo seems a bit pixelated.
Other than that I say you've done yourself proud
BTW: I cant seem to find anything "unusual" about your style.css coding. Is it a syntax easter egg or are there specific words that I should be looking for?