[Roushey]

Well think about it this way.
Even if their animation does win at another regional, they have slim chances of beating the same animation (that it lost to in the first place) again at nationals. All's they are getting is a little plastic trophy.

I will admit that the student judging does have its flaws, but I think it is a positive thing because you're thrown in a room with a bunch of fellow animators, which is alot of fun. Its also a good time to chat about hardships, techniques, and other animation details. Furthermore, you gain feedback on your animation from your peers. Directly. Which is Very helpful.