View Single Post
  #3   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 04-04-2005, 21:56
Spikey's Avatar
Spikey Spikey is offline
Its NOT a Camera
AKA: College Advisor
FRC #0293 (SPIKE)
Team Role: Mentor
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Rookie Year: 2001
Location: A tiny spec in New Jersey
Posts: 225
Spikey is just really niceSpikey is just really niceSpikey is just really niceSpikey is just really nice
Re: When do mentors go too far?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dave Flowerday
The defensive response is because the original poster and some follow-ups implied that such teams are somehow cheating their students out of an opportunity, by asking questions like "What is the point of robotics if adults are the ones designing, engineering, building, and servicing the robot?"

The fact that these conclusions are reached on false information (that the robots in question actually are not 100% adult built) is simply salt in the wound.
I'm in no way trying to present false information, I am just reporting my experience through interactions with other teams and mentors. I have talked to mentors who have advised teams that have the students tell the engineers what they want, then the students see the finished product a few weeks later.
I'm not saying that these students should feel cheated, they are free to feel however they want too. Maybe they like having an adult built robot that performs well and wins all the time.
I acknowledge that part of FIRST is about inspiration, but inspiration cannot have a full effect without interaction. Teams that truly inspire students to pursue engineering involve those students in the process. Hands on experience is the way robotics inspires students to get involved in engineering. Even if some students choose not to build their robot because they deal with other aspects of FIRST seeing other students work on the robot can be inspiring as well.
__________________
It's not a bug it's a feature!
"No, you may not drill holes in the air tanks to lighten them." -FIRST Q&A Repsonse to a question about lightening air tanks.
I'm the Not a Camera Kid at the New Jersey Regional But Not This Year, I am at Syracuse University Class of 2009
Uncrowned Champions of the 2005 Philadelphia Regional
SPIKE X NJ Xerox Creativity Award. Chesapeake Regional CHAMPIONS, and Motorola Quality Award
2006 Semi-Finalist at NJ Regional & Semi-Finalist at Chesapeake Regional, winners of the 2006 Xerox Creativity Award, and Judges Award
"Looks like SPIKE is doing its Batman thing again, that team looked like it was going to score, but SPIKE was not going to allow that to happen" -Play by play call at the Chesapeake Regional