Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Eugenia Gabrielov
I'm in the class of too close to decide.
As movies go:
Episodes IV - VI > LOTR > Episode III
Episodes I-II count as bloopers -_-.
As literature goes, you guys have to realize that you won't understand LOTR movies until you read LOTR books, including the ultra-long Silmarillion. There is so much there that you can't get from a film.
So with books, LOTR tops Star Wars with immense ease.
|
You don't
need to read the books to get the movies, but it sure does help.
I've read 2/3 of the trilogy, and The Hobbit, and surprisingly, I actually like the movies more. Probably because I saw them first though.