[Stu Bloom]

I was a bit disturbed to see this thread resurrected after lying dormant for almost three weeks. I basically agree with Alan in that I think this question is both misguided and unproductive. However I will concede that my uneasiness could be a positive sign that my ideas are being challenged as I am being forced to consider options I don't like ...

As I read the responses here one thing strikes me. Most of the posts refer to "teaching" the students in one way or another. I challenge all to remember:

For INSPIRATION and RECOGNITION of Science and Technology

I don't see anything there about teaching or education. The original goal/purpose of FIRST was to inspire students to pursue careers in science and technology by having them work with engineers and immersing them in technology. In my opinion that hasn't changed, nor should it. I would agree with most here that maximum inspiration will come from maximum hands-on involvement in every aspect of this robotics project that we all love. I still don't think this poll is "answerable" because I could never choose between the two options offered. But every team will find their own way down this path and figure out how they can best inspire their students.