[AmyPrib]

My initial reactions, as it turned into a more positive thread:

- Field is empty!
- Expecting less diversity in robot design than say in '04, but we'll see.
- "Relatively" one-dimensional/one-tasked game
- Hope they put netting around the field!
- Wow that ramp is steep.
- The camera's back. I think that's good, going for multiple year usage so people really get a chance to use it.
- This game is spectator and media friendly. With the likeness of basketball, football, hockey, sports, non-FIRSTers might get even more excited.

After Reading the Manual:
- The game rules are well-written compared to previous years! Very clear and understandable, with a few minor exceptions (that I've seen discussed). So far, I find very little room for loop-holes and confusion if you read them thoroughly.
- It seems like the refs job might be slightly less stressful, as there shouldn't be too many discretion or opinion calls needed and they can focus on robot position and interaction.
- The points/penalties are balanced! Woohoo!
- Pretty much all the penalties are the same amt, 5pts! Woohoo!
- Unlimited scoring! I hope those sensors work!
- They have obviously taken into account (while writing the rules) to cover and clearly state their intent of a rule to minimize the amount of "lawyering" that can be done.
- They have addressed many of the confusions and complaints from previous years (in game section at least).
- Wow, they went to serpentine alliance selections (1 to 8 pick, then back down 8 to 1 pick). Will be interesting.
- Size restrictions - mixed feelings. Sorta relates to the less diversity note. I am amazed at some of the things teams come up with when unfolded, expanded, etc. But this will definitely challenge creativity in design.

They aren't grouped in good or bad. In general I think this will be a great game and we'll see how it turns out. I still contend the '04 game itself (aside from rule/penalty debates) has been the most exciting yet. We'll see if this overrides that.