As a website judge of two years, I sympathize with your request. The website award USED to be peer judged, but FIRST did away with that (forgive me, but I can't remember why). As it is now, the FIRST judges are given a list of competing teams, their websites, and a long form to fill out. EVERY judge is required to score AND leave a comment about EVERY website. I'm really surprised they do not forward these comments and suggestions onto the teams, as this would be INCREDIBLY helpful to improve well into the future.
Okay, bragging rights now, Team 1089 (my team) won the website award at the NJ Regional this year. If you would like, please feel free to stop by our website and compare/contrast with ours (
http://www.mercury1089.com ). I worked with the students this year to supply a massive amount of content and work with the fluidity and interactivity of it as well. If you would like to talk to me about what I personally think is important in a FIRST award-winning website, feel free to PM me.