Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Steve W
First of all your robot design has not been copyrighted. Secondly I must try and reproduce something that you have designed. I am not taking the product that you created as you are if you take music that someone else recorded. The fact that if you design something for your robot and copyrighted it then it would be wrong for me to copy it without your permission.
When you use your time, utilities, equipment and expertise to "copy" (as in copyright) music, are you also using your musicians, your singing, your abilities to try and clone the music just as if it were a robot part?
|
I'm going to assume by copyrighted you meant patented. This is where real world analogies break down.
Lets say that my friend
buys a CD from the store. He goes "Hey Mike, this song is pretty good, you might like it." and then sends me that song. I didn't pay for that song, yet I now have it on my computer. My friend was just trying to be... well... friendly and we are now eligible to be put into a position of extortion by the RIAA. What if I say "This song is worse than the US' foreign affairs policy" and delete it, should I still be prosecuted?
What if I happen to like the song, should I now delete it and go pay $15 in order for another executive to afford his fifth Porsche?
My friend purchased the CD, is it not for him to do what he wishes with it? If this includes giving out
free (not for profit) copies to his friends, and the RIAA has a problem with that, they should not have sold him the CD.