[EricH]

I'm going to say that this is from the animation (as has been said already.) However, I'm also going to say this one thing....

TRIPLE REPLAY!!!

Let's see here: 5 can refer to anything, but the 2005 clue was on baseball. It looks like a goal from 2005 is in the bottom right corner. I'm going to guess something has changed a bit, though.

Other thoughts:
Post 5 in the Game Design thread has a game that is pretty good, possibly played on diamond plate.

The fifth game was suggested by Billfred (last year's "winner"), but is a little crazy.

Then again, the 4th game involved 5 moving goals.

Oh, no, I'm losing my mind already!