View Single Post
  #25   Spotlight this post!  
Unread 05-03-2007, 23:42
ScoutingNerd175's Avatar
ScoutingNerd175 ScoutingNerd175 is offline
Scouting Away
AKA: Caroline Marr
FRC #0175 (Buzz Robotics)
Team Role: Alumni
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Rookie Year: 2005
Location: Enfield, CT
Posts: 231
ScoutingNerd175 has much to be proud ofScoutingNerd175 has much to be proud ofScoutingNerd175 has much to be proud ofScoutingNerd175 has much to be proud ofScoutingNerd175 has much to be proud ofScoutingNerd175 has much to be proud ofScoutingNerd175 has much to be proud ofScoutingNerd175 has much to be proud of
Send a message via AIM to ScoutingNerd175
Re: Veteran Teams have No Advantage

Our scouting team took data on the number of tetras/balls actually scored by robots at the regionals we were attending. This may be more reflective of how teams are actually scoring. The only data I have access to at the moment is the data for the 2005 Chesapeake Bay Regional. So, out of 55 teams at the regional, 25 (45%) were numbered above 1000 (arbitrary number) with 9 (16.3%) being rookies. Looking at just the top 8 (scorers, not seeds), 2 (25%) were numbered over 1000, 1 (12.5%) was a rookie team. If I pick an arbitrary number again, like 2 tetras, 36% of teams that scored 2+ tetras were numbered over 1000 and 18% were rookies.



So I'm not sure if this data is in any way meaningful, but it may be more meaningful if someone keeps data on scoring, or something along those lines, to compare that to team number (in a more meaningful way than this) or to compare scoring to seed this year and last year (for example what % of the top 8 seeds were also in the top 8 scoring this years as compared to last year) to see if this algorithm is having an effect on where the highest scoring teams seed. (I can't do that here because I don't know the seeds for 2005 Chesapeake)

Or it might all be meaningless. But match results definitely do not equal scoring ability (the highest scoring robot in the Curie division at 2005 Championships was seeded 11th). Although, scoring ability definitely does not equal robot quality.
__________________
Buzz 175 Alumna

University of Michigan, Class of 2012
Syracuse University, Class of 2010
Enrico Fermi High School, Class of 2006