[meaubry]

The whole thing of defining possesion based on it getting stuck on the flag is kinda stupid.

If herding, which also defines possesion is ruled this way - what is the big deal to clarify the same for tubes caught on flags?

Here is the 'official' answer as found in the FIRST Q&A:

"HERDING" implies that you are attempting to direct multiple Game Pieces to a particular location. Merely driving into an area occupied by multiple Game Pieces in an attempt to clear the area and letting them randomly scatter would not be considered herding.

Clearly, the words "attempting to direct" & "particular location", imply intent.

As with flag ringers - intent is extremely doubtful. Accidental is more like it, even when attempting to get one on an opponent, it takes alot of luck.

Isn't the fact that the team has to deal with the obstruction of having a tube stuck on the flag pole enough of a penalty?

Sorry - but this is one rule that is really unneccessary (especially when everyone isn't mounting the flags per the required specifications).