[EHaskins]

Try connecting it to a Windows Vista computer.

I had a drive I borrowed to a classmate to get a file off of, and they pulled it out without doing a Safely Remove. Surprise, it wouldn't mount in WinXP. I plugged it into my Vista laptop, and it automatically detected the error(s) and recovered all the data, except the file that was being accessed. (too bad, at least I got most of it back)