[EricH]

Originally Posted by Kimberly

If the algorithm were changed to include the fewest pairings of rookie teams possible, and to balance the rookie distribution between the competing alliances, it wouldn't matter what percentage rookies were at the competition. It would only mean there wouldn't be alliances where experienced teams were competing against inexperienced.

I don't know how easy that would be to implement for next year. (It's too late for this year.) I think it won't be that easy.

Take a look at the 2007 match lists, if you can find any. (The Blue Alliance probably has them.) You will see almost exactly that situation. The hard part will be keeping the other teams from facing each other more than once or twice. Last year's algorithm was the most hated in FRC history. So you want the "third tier" to be made up only of rookies and only one other tier. That can't be easy to do. If you think it is, then I invite you to come up with an algorithm and submit it to FIRST for their use.